You are here

Frameworks of Power
Share

Frameworks of Power



July 1989 | 320 pages | SAGE Publications Ltd
"Both a comprehensive historical and theoretical overview of the concept of power, and a substantive and original contribution to debates in that literature. . .Clegg has succeeded remarkably well on both counts. First, his book is a wide-ranging and nuanced overview and critique of theories of power stretching from Hobbes to Foucault. Second, Clegg spends the last third of the book presenting an alternative conception of power that is both theoretically sophisticated and powerfully insightful. Clegg provides insightful and evocative critiques of many of the standard debates on power, although his reading of Gidden's structuration theory should be of particular interest to communication scholars." --Communication Theory "This book can be read in a variety of ways. The early chapters will serve very well as a more-than-just-a-textbook guide to the existing paradigms of power analysis, while the later sections sketch out an extremely stimulating agenda for further work. . . .Clegg has done an excellent job in bringing out the relevance of recent French work on power. . . ." --The Sociological Review "This important book reopens the debate about power in modern society. The book starts where Steven Lukes and Anthony Giddens left the controversy several years ago, but Clegg redirects the debate, by reconceptualizing power as an organizational phenomenon. Organization provides the "framework of power," and without knowledge of this framework power cannot be adequately conceptualized. As such, this book invigorates both the debates on power and the entire field of organizational studies." --Gary G. Hamilton, University of California, Davis "I have read the manuscript and find it most impressive. Using the giants of the past--Hobbes and Machiavelli--as a starting point, Clegg presents an integrated framework with the giants of the present--Giddens and Luke. In the process, Clegg makes some important original contributions to the development and use of concepts related to power." --Richard H. Hall, SUNY, Albany "An ambitious book, spanning the theoretical issues of sociology from the most micro to the most macro dimensions of analysis. Clegg's work is on the frontier of current thinking in the social sciences." --Randall Collins, University of California, Riverside "This is just what I was looking for: a thorough, balanced, and above all, readable account of the central concept of politics which takes us from Hobbes through all the major writers to Foucault. It is an admirable clear statement of the classics, and an attempt to go beyond them. It will immediately go in the 'essential reading' part of my graduate and undergraduate course lists." --Ken Newton, University of Essex "Provides a wealth of information about the modern approaches to power on a theoretical plane. It is well written and extremely well documented and provides a very useful guideline to the development of modern thinking in this area." --The Alternative Newsletter: Newsletter of the Section of Alternative Dispute Resolution Association of American Law Schools "The book not only provides an interesting and readable discussion of major texts on power in social theory, but also it provides an interesting framework for the analysis of power that deserves further attention." --Accounting Auditing and Accountability "This book should be of substantial interest to communication scholars. " --Quarterly Journal of Speech "Should be widely adopted as a teaching text: no alternative is so up-to- date, or so adept in identifying and interpreting recent developments. This is a book which has put itself at the service of the literature, and as an analysis of the literature, rather than of what the literature itself purports to analyse, it must be considered a success." --Sociology What are the different frameworks for understanding power which have been developed within the social sciences? In particular, how has classical sociological literature as well as the literature of the last decade discussed the variety of approaches to power? In Frameworks of Power, Clegg provides a comprehensive account of the different approaches to understanding power and, in the process, presents a fresh synthesis. This innovative overview opens with the classic literature on power as expressed by Machiavelli and Hobbes. Clegg then addresses more recent analyses. Included are the works of American political and social theorists, such as Robert Dahl, Peter Bacharach, Morton Baratz, and Talcott Parsons; the British sociologists, Steven Luke, Anthony Giddens and Michael Mann; the German critical theorist, J_rgen Habermas; and the increasingly important contributions of the French school, Michel Foucault, Bruno Latour and Michel Callon. Out of this discussion emerges a new model of "circuits of power," drawing on important recent advances in the sociology of science and the sociology of organizations. This approach is then applied to key questions of comparative historical sociology: the emergence of the modern state in Western Europe. The first to incorporate diverse frameworks for the analysis of power in a single volume, Frameworks of Power will be essential reading for scholars in the fields of sociology, political science, and organizational studies.
 
Frameworks of Power
An Overview of the Argument

 
 
Power
Traditional Roots, Modern Problems

 
 
Political Community, Methodological Procedures and the Agency Model
 
The Power of Intention and Structure
 
Lukes' Dimensions and Epistemology
 
Giddens' Critique of Parsons and the Duality of Structure
 
Post-Structuralism, Sovereign Power and Disciplinary Power
 
Circuits of Power
A Framework for Analysis

 
 
Constituting Circuits of Power in Modernity

`While Frameworks of Power is ostensibly directed at scholars in organization studies, it clearly has a much wider domain, addressing concerns pivotal to social theory as a whole. Clegg provides insightful and evocative critiques of the standard debates on power' - Communication Theory

`Clegg provides a useful textbook discussion of the modern literature and draws from it an ingenious model of his own' - Political Studies

`should be widely adopted as a teaching text: no alternative is so up-to-date, or so adept in identifying and interpreting recent developments' - Sociology

`It is to our benefit that Stewart Clegg has laboured so assiduously to bring clarity and lucidity to [the] concept [of power]... the book presents and addresses a multiplicity of debates around power, particularly those which have taken place in English-speaking regions in the 20th centruy. Yet it is more than this, it is also a developed theoretical statement, an attempt to enunciate and illustrate a particular framework of power around the idea of 'circuits' of power. Clegg's knowledge and exposition of the field are extremely thorough and border on the prodigious... the range of themes is itself extraordinary.' - Prometheus

`a particularly clear and incisive survey of the field, and a stimulating and important contribution to the on-going debate over the nature of power... As well as the carefully argued writing style in the analytical tradition, there are passages of a different writing... [that] suggest that Clegg took pleasure in the writing. All power to his keyboard. The result is a book that we and our students can approach with the expectation that we will not only benefit from it, but enjoy the read' - APROS Bulletin

`an ambitious book, spanning the theoretical issues of sociology from the most micro to the most macro dimensions of analysis. Clegg integrates the theory of power with the sociology of organizations, and shows us the relationships among social cognition, class structure, organizational processes and historical change. Clegg's work is on the frontier of current thinking in the social sciences' - Randall Collins, Professor of Sociology, University of California, Riverside

`Comprehensive and systematic, Stewart Clegg has given us a masterly survey of theories of power, from Machiavelli to postmodernism.... it is a major contribution to contemporary social theory' - Bryan S Turner, University of Utrecht

`This is just what I was looking for: a thorough, balanced, and above all, readable account of the central concept of politics which takes us from Hobbes through all the major writers to Foucault. It is an admirably clear statementof the classics, and an attempt to go beyond them. It will immediately go in the `Essential Reading' part of my graduate and undergraduate course lists' - Professor Kenneth Newton

`brilliant... fills a gap in the sociological literature... the theoretical framework is especially relevant to redefine the sociological debate' - Professor Lucien Karpik, Centre de Sociologie de l'Innovation, l'Ecole des Mines

`This important book reopens the debate about power in modern society. The book starts where Steven Lukes and Anthony Giddens left the controversy several years ago, but Clegg redirects the debate, by reconceptualizing power as an organizational phenomenon. Organization provides the `framework of power', and without knowledge of this framework power cannot be adequately conceptualized. As such, this book invigorates both the debates on power and the entire field of organizational studies. - Gary G Hamilton, Professor of Sociology, University of California, Davis

`A distinctive, even outstanding, consideration of power, remarkably informed and thoughtful... bringing together European and American thinking past and present.' - Professor David J Hickson, University of Bradford

`a comprehensive analysis of the various discussions of power in current social theory and criticism. This book should be of substantial interest to communication scholars' - Quarterly Journal of Speech `most impressive. Using the giants of the past - Hobbes and Machiavelli - as a starting point, Clegg presents an integrated framework with the giants of the present - Giddens and Lukes. In the process, Clegg makes some important original contributions to the development and use of concepts related to power' - Richard Hall, Professor of Sociology, SUNY Albany

`the book not only provides an interesting and readable discussion of major texts on power in social theory, but also provides an interesting framework for the analysis of power that deserves further attention.' - Accounting, Auditing and Accountability

`In Frameworks of Power, he apparently sets himself an almost impossible task. He attempts to produce a work that is both a comprehensive historical and theoretical overview of the concept of power, and a substantive and original contribution to debates in that literature. However, Clegg has succeeded remarkably well on both counts. First, his book is a wide-ranging and nuanced overview and critique of theories of power stretching from Hobbes to Foucault. Second, Clegg spends the last third of the book presenting an alternative conception of power that is both theoretically sophisticated and powerfully insightful....While Frameworks of Power is ostensibly directed at scholars in organization studies, it clearly has a much wider domain, addressing concerns pivotal to social theory as a whole. Clegg provides insightful and evocative critiques of many of the standard debates on power, although his reading of Gidden's structuration theory should be of particular interest to communication scholars.' - Communication Theory

Preview this book

Stewart R. Clegg

Stewart Clegg is a prolific publisher of several hundred articles in leading academic journals in strategy, social science, management and organization theory; is also the author and editor of about fifty books, as well as a Fellow of the British Academy of Social Sciences, a Distinguished Fellow of the Australian and New Zealand Academy of Management, a Fellow of the Academy of the Social Sciences in Australia, and the recipient of significant awards from the American Academy of Management for his contributions to management theory and practice. More About Author

For instructors

To inquire about the availability of this title for review (print and/or digital), please contact your local sales representative or call (800) 818-7243.

Purchasing options

Please select a format:

ISBN: 9780803981614
£43.99 
ISBN: 9780803981607
£108.00 

SAGE Knowledge is the ultimate social sciences digital library for students, researchers, and faculty. Hosting more than 4,400 titles, it includes an expansive range of SAGE eBook and eReference content, including scholarly monographs, reference works, handbooks, series, professional development titles, and more.

The platform allows researchers to cross-search and seamlessly access a wide breadth of must-have SAGE book and reference content from one source.